The Official Arguments Against AA
This is one of the largest parcel tax proposals in Oakland’s history.
It was put on the ballot without community input and without a plan on how to spend the $30,000,000 a year the measure would generate. Lost in the details of the measure is the fact that the money can be used to fund the growing bureaucracy of the city.
We share the wonderful goals of this 15-page ballot measure. Unfortunately, we don’t see any realistic steps to reaching them. “Give us the money and we’ll figure out how to do it” is not acceptable.
Who controls the estimated $30 million annually? New, unnamed city employees. But nothing in this measure holds public employees accountable for all this money! A “Citizens’ Oversight Commission” is created, but its members would be handpicked by city bureaucrats.
The “Oakland Promise Fund” is full of promises to “increase early college awareness and expectations” and fincrease college persistence and graduation rates.” How? What exactly is the plan? There is no plan. Over and over we’ve seen similar taxes raising money with good intentions but without clear programs. Local organizations are promised funding and taxpayers get the bill.
While we share Mayor Libby Schaaf’s commitment to address persistent problems with the Oakland schools, this initiative is deeply flawed. Our children deserve better! This measure will last 30 years, long past the term of this Mayor.
Oakland children, born today will be over 30 before this tax expires.
Rather than work with the Council or the School District to prioritize funding for Oakland’s children, Schaaf is passing the buck to homeowners without a realistic plan.
Despite the feel good language, this ‘Initiative’ is nothing but another thinly disguised attempt to raise more moneyfor programs that sound good but yield little results.
–Official Argument against this Tax
-But an Appeals Court Allowed it. Mind You, A California Appeals Court. Beware of any Tax initiatives in California.
This Needs to be Argued on a Federal Level. Fairness in Elections. Changing Election Rules, After The Fact? Beware of ANY Tax Initiatives in Oakland.
With the “stacking” of RCV, You have to wonder. Is any Oakland Election Fair?
-Think Oakland